The Pet Avengers consists of Lockjaw of the Inhumans, Lockheed of X-Men, the Falcon's falcon Redwing, frog-Thor Throg, Ka-Zar's Zabu, and a cat and a dog. Here, they're out to protect the Earth from Fin Fang Foom and his band of dragons – or are they?
This is a collection of a four-issue miniseries, written by Eliopolous and with art by Ig Guara, with a bonus story by Eliopolous about Thor having been turned into a frog and getting help from Spider-Man, inspired by Walter Simonson having briefly turned Thor into a frog in the eighties.
Anyway, the main story starts out by showing Fin Fang Foom and a whole bunch of dragons arriving from space ages ago, first being revered almost as gods, and then being hunted into almost-extinction by the humans. After being given an elixir, Fin (or Foom, if you prefer) fell asleep and would sleep for centuries. That brings us to contemporary times and the Pet Avengers stopping a robber. Then, Throg receives a telepathic message from Thor that the original Avengers are in trouble, and the group uses Lockjaw's teleportation powers to transport themselves to help them out. Turns out the Avengers are in a battle with Foom (or Fin, if you prefer) and are in bad trouble – not least because Thor, Iron Man and Captain America have been turned into frogs.
The Pet Avengers join the fray – but Lockheed suddenly decides to take a stand with his fellow dragons, and after a somewhat lengthy discussion persuades his friends to help him and the dragons hold off the Avengers while Fin Fang Foom goes into the ground to retrieve something... (That'll have to do for a plot summary; I don't want to give away too much of the story.)
I really expected to like this comic. I mean, the Pet Avengers? How could that not be good?
Turns out it could, by a) not having adequate art, b) not having adequate writing. The cover of issue #4 illustrating this post is also the cover of the collection, and is symptomatic of the art problem. If you look at it, you wouldn't know that there is a problem, but the colors of paperback cover is significantly darker, killing a lot of Guara's line art. The same problem is prevalent inside the book; murky coloring makes it difficult to make out what's happening in many instances, and even when it's not, you're still robbed of the experience of Guara's line art. So a big Fail for the coloring and/or production of this book, then.
Also, the writing suffers from trying to be both a traditional Marvel action/adventure story and funny, I believe, and Eliopolous doesn't manage to pull that off. The big fight between the dragons and the Avengers is too drawn-out and to erratically paced, shifting between action and debate (though in fairness, some of my problem with that may be due to the dark, murky colors pretty much killing the action sequences). Even more problematically, having Thor, Cap and Iron Man turned into frogs seems just tacked on to the story; it doesn't contribute anything at all and isn't used to make any special points about heroism, either. Instead, it comes off as if Eliopolous just thought, "hey, wouldn't it be neat to have Thor, Cap and Iron Man turned into frogs?". But it's not neat enough that it can stand on its own; you have to actually do something with it as well. Instead, they're frogs, remain frogs for an issue or so, and are then returned to human form. That's it, and it's not enough.
So the main part of this book doesn't work, and you can't even buy it to just enjoy the artwork.
The last story, however, is drawn by Eliopolous himself in his own cartoony style, and it works better. It's a single-issue story from Spider-Man Family depicting how Loki gets Thor turned into a frog, and how Thor is then captured by the guy who delivers frogs to the local high school for dissection, and who happens to get him as his subject if not Peter Parker? Thor must somehow convey to Peter that he isn't just any old frog, and then find Loki and defeat him (with the help of the Amazing Spider-Man, of course).
This piece worked better because it was less pretentious and simply told its story in a straight fashion, and Eliopolous' art worked very nicely for it (it helped that it wasn't killed by insensitive coloring). But I can't recommend a book because one-fifth of it works, so I won't. Try Chris Giarrusso's Mini Marvels Ultimate Collection instead, which is both funnier, more readable, and better at characterization.
Visar inlägg med etikett New Avengers. Visa alla inlägg
Visar inlägg med etikett New Avengers. Visa alla inlägg
lördag 2 juli 2011
tisdag 17 maj 2011
Brian Michael Bendis & David Finch: The New Avengers 1: Breakout
Brian Michael Bendis is apparently somewhat of a superstar these days. For the last decade, I haven't had the money to follow the US comics scene as I used to do, and I'm still sufficiently unhappy with Marvel's pricing policy that I don't care to follow their stuff particularly closely, but with my incomes going up again (unfortunately at the cost of working more), I've been filling out some holes in my collection. Initially concentrating on Essentials, I've also been getting a bunch of regular TPBs – and one of those has been the first New Avengers collection, happily for me.
I've mainly good things to say about the book. Finch is a good artist, and the inkers have generally done a good job over his pencils. It's strong in composition and anatomy, and the line art looks great; in one chapter, the line looks somewhat like good younger-generation Kubert inked with just a hint of Gerry Talaoc elegance – not too much, to give it that sort of "oily" look that I think a lot of the Filipino inkers of the seventies brought to the page, but just a hint. (Sadly, I don't know which inker is responsible for which pages.) Unfortunately, the colors sometimes overpower the line art (as happens so frequently with computer coloring), and when they go for "dark & moody", the result is just "murky & hard-to-read". Mostly, though, the colors are good, and overall the art is very good.
The writing is good, too. The story is as follows: Attorney Matt Murdock is at a prison for super-powered beings (chaperoned by Spider-Woman and bodyguarded by Luke Cage) to talk with Sentry when a prison break occurs. By chance, Captain America and Spiderman happen upon the the scene as well, and Iron Man also arrives to lend a hand. Together, they manage to keep the prison break down to just a minor disaster instead of a full-blown one, but there are still 40+ super-criminals on the loose. The next day, Cap makes Iron Man a suggestion: Why not restart the Avengers? They did good together, and they are sorely needed to stop those super-baddies on the loose. Tony Stark doesn't quite have the money to bankroll the Avengers these days, but Cap, who is very hard to say no to, persuades him that they can do it on the cheap. Cap then proceeds to persuade Spider-Woman, Cage, and Spider-Man to join as well. As (IIRC) Tony Stark puts it, Cap is a very hard person to say no to... (Although Daredevil and Sentry manage to, at least initially.)
So the team reassembles, and under the leadership of Cap and Iron Man manage to negotiate the hot waters of government bureaucracy as well as kick some serious do-badder butt... But will it be enough to counter the danger that is building in the Forgotten Land?
I won't go into the plot more than that; you deserve to read it yourself. The good thing about Bendis' writing is that it flows very well and that he manages to do a lot of characterization in the dialogue without it coming off as contrived. Also, a lot of what Bendis does with the characters is really good: Luke Cage learns what it means to be in the really big leagues; Cap and Iron Man put snotty S.H.I.E.L.D. directors in their place without being rude about it, just very firm and confident in their status as top-line government-endorsed superheroes; Cap is impressed by Peter Parker's dedication and guts; practically everybody is (justly) impressed by Cap – I love the line about how it's nearly impossible to say no to Cap when he asks something of you, not just because he's a living legend but also because he's so totally honest, true-blue and earnest. Etc.
I do have some quibbles with Bendis' writing, though. Apparently, he lists Aaron Sorkin as one of his favorite writers, and there is indeed a certain TV-ish quality, something of a Sorkinesque glibness to some of the dialogue – as if it tries to press just a little bit too much info and cleverness into too-short pieces of dialogue, where taking a couple of panels more to let it develop more naturally would have worked better. He also occasionally tries to have his characters and the situations they're be more adult than the writing can really support, which leads to it looking a bit silly instead – which is of course also something you can see on TV shows occasionally. But overall, Bendis does good here, and this is a good, strong superhero book. Recommended.
The views of another reviewer here.
I've mainly good things to say about the book. Finch is a good artist, and the inkers have generally done a good job over his pencils. It's strong in composition and anatomy, and the line art looks great; in one chapter, the line looks somewhat like good younger-generation Kubert inked with just a hint of Gerry Talaoc elegance – not too much, to give it that sort of "oily" look that I think a lot of the Filipino inkers of the seventies brought to the page, but just a hint. (Sadly, I don't know which inker is responsible for which pages.) Unfortunately, the colors sometimes overpower the line art (as happens so frequently with computer coloring), and when they go for "dark & moody", the result is just "murky & hard-to-read". Mostly, though, the colors are good, and overall the art is very good.
The writing is good, too. The story is as follows: Attorney Matt Murdock is at a prison for super-powered beings (chaperoned by Spider-Woman and bodyguarded by Luke Cage) to talk with Sentry when a prison break occurs. By chance, Captain America and Spiderman happen upon the the scene as well, and Iron Man also arrives to lend a hand. Together, they manage to keep the prison break down to just a minor disaster instead of a full-blown one, but there are still 40+ super-criminals on the loose. The next day, Cap makes Iron Man a suggestion: Why not restart the Avengers? They did good together, and they are sorely needed to stop those super-baddies on the loose. Tony Stark doesn't quite have the money to bankroll the Avengers these days, but Cap, who is very hard to say no to, persuades him that they can do it on the cheap. Cap then proceeds to persuade Spider-Woman, Cage, and Spider-Man to join as well. As (IIRC) Tony Stark puts it, Cap is a very hard person to say no to... (Although Daredevil and Sentry manage to, at least initially.)
So the team reassembles, and under the leadership of Cap and Iron Man manage to negotiate the hot waters of government bureaucracy as well as kick some serious do-badder butt... But will it be enough to counter the danger that is building in the Forgotten Land?
I won't go into the plot more than that; you deserve to read it yourself. The good thing about Bendis' writing is that it flows very well and that he manages to do a lot of characterization in the dialogue without it coming off as contrived. Also, a lot of what Bendis does with the characters is really good: Luke Cage learns what it means to be in the really big leagues; Cap and Iron Man put snotty S.H.I.E.L.D. directors in their place without being rude about it, just very firm and confident in their status as top-line government-endorsed superheroes; Cap is impressed by Peter Parker's dedication and guts; practically everybody is (justly) impressed by Cap – I love the line about how it's nearly impossible to say no to Cap when he asks something of you, not just because he's a living legend but also because he's so totally honest, true-blue and earnest. Etc.
I do have some quibbles with Bendis' writing, though. Apparently, he lists Aaron Sorkin as one of his favorite writers, and there is indeed a certain TV-ish quality, something of a Sorkinesque glibness to some of the dialogue – as if it tries to press just a little bit too much info and cleverness into too-short pieces of dialogue, where taking a couple of panels more to let it develop more naturally would have worked better. He also occasionally tries to have his characters and the situations they're be more adult than the writing can really support, which leads to it looking a bit silly instead – which is of course also something you can see on TV shows occasionally. But overall, Bendis does good here, and this is a good, strong superhero book. Recommended.
The views of another reviewer here.
Prenumerera på:
Inlägg (Atom)

